McMath Realty Property Management

Do not use this management company. I was warned they would steal part or all of your security deposit when you leave and then it happened to me. They blatantly lied about things like nail holes in the wall when I never hung a picture the whole time I lived there. $900 charge to clean a house. $900 charge to trim a few bushes. Absolutely outrageous prices for these services. Claiming I left with burnt out lights bulbs that I replaced right before I left and charged a ridiculous amount. You will get back only a portion of that security deposit if any. Do not use them.

Stay away from any properties using this agency. They did not have the property ready for move in. Then, when we moved out, they had the audacity to charge over a thousand dollars to repair drywall where we did not touch a single wall, to respect the owners property. We left it in a better state than when we got it but still was taken advantage of by these scammers. As a landlord, they do not work in your best interest for repeat customers as well as maintaining the property. Many issues!!! The positive is that repairs would be taken care of in a reasonable amount of time.

Our experience with McMath as a rental agency was a huge letdown. Right from the beginning, the property manager, Michael, and the company itself didn't live up to expectations. The manager's rude and dismissive responses should've been a red flag, but we foolishly went ahead and rented from them anyway. Turns out, his disrespectful attitude was a constant throughout our entire lease. Sure, he was decent when it came to fixing house issues we encountered, but other than that, he was just plain rude. And it wasn't just him; the whole office, including the office manager Denise, treated tenants with complete disrespect. It's as if they prioritize landlords over tenants, considering tenants beneath them or something. You would think McMath would understand that without tenants, they wouldn't

I cannot say enough good things about McMath Realty. We are new to investor property ownership and had lots of questions. Weldon McMath talked about the details of property ownership and even answered a bunch of my e-mailed questions on Super Bowl Sunday! Our property is a newly constructed home and Tyler Nick met us at the house prior to completion to answer any remaining questions we had. Tyler is great. He is very communicative and always returns calls quickly. He has worked with us very closely with the tenant during the 1st year of construction warranty period. I highly recommend McMath Realty and Tyler Nick to any property investor in the Phoenix area.

I've been renting with McMath for a little over a year. They have been very easy to deal with and always helpful and professional. Recently I had the unpleasant experience of having our AC unit fail in the middle of the night. By 8 am I had be in contact with my property manager and the repair company and had the unit fixed later that day. Overall the whole process was smooth, easy and handled with efficiency and professionalism. I couldn't have asked for anything more.